
Don't miss this one! Watch Dr. Kanner talk about how children understand time at different levels of development and much differently than adults this Monday, June 23rd @ 8:15am on Fox6 News In The Morning
Background:
As parents, have you ever noticed how depending upon the age of your
child, discussing time issues can be both confusing and frustrating?
One of the easiest mistakes as adults is the assumption that children
understand time in the same manner as we do. Even more confusing is
that as they mature, time is then managed in a different fashion and it
is easily then misunderstood that the child is now being "better
behaved", rather than his or her brain maturing to the level of being
able to tolerate and process information in a more formalized manner.
Therefore, it is no surprise when our children, depending upon his
or her age, do not necessarily cooperate with our requests for
compliance to perform tasks in the same way we might like them to or
react to other issues relating to time like having to wait a while for
a treat. For example my 7 year old son becomes very frustrated with me
whenever I cannot do something with him at a particular time on a
particular day. Just last weekend, we discussed building a go-cart
together for a fun father-son project and he expected in his mind that
this was going to happen "just then". When I explained to him that I
had to do a little research on go-carts, safety, and where to get
one,his immediate comment, based on feeling excited and then frustrated
(normal for a 7 year old) was "this is never going to happen". Even
with my detailed explanation of the process of research, searching, and
buying, in the mind of a 7 year old, "today is the day".
My 5 year old is a completely different story. Still living part
time in the wonderful world of magical thinking, time for him is filled
with fantasy and excitement and when something does not happen
immediately, his fantasy life keeps the wish perpetual. For example,
he loves gardening with me, which he would do 24/7, but when I cannot
at that moment, his magical mind cannot separate one day from the other
and therefore our fun activity stays alive in fantasy and buys me some
time.
Now, my almost 10 year old daughter is completely different. She
has has the cognitive (thinking) capacity to not only tell time, but
also to think both in the past and a little into the future, so she is
then able to better tolerate frustration better than my 7 year
old(which is still tough for any children!).
Such examples, which I am sure many of you can relate to, are not
behavioral issues per se, but based on what a child is functionally
able to do based on their age and level of development. It is true
that some children mature faster than others, but in most cases,
cognitive (thinking) and emotional (feeling) development changes over
time based on physiological, and neurological maturation. Often times,
when parents come to visit me, they are happy to hear that what their
child is doing or saying is absolutely "normal" for where they are
developmentally and it was a good idea to check it out before assuming
that their child was having some sort of a psychological problem. In a
nutshell, we cannot expect a child to perform a task if their mind and
body are not yet capable. We can see then how when some parents do not
understand the normality of certain concepts, they may respond to their
children in ways which could do more harm than good.
Back to the time issue with children for example, as indicated in
my personal stories, children under the age of 4 view time in magical
ways. They do not know how to tell time and time is very grandiose.
As parents, this is helpful for 30 minutes of our time with a 4 year
old feels almost like forever and is held in fantasy for quite awhile.
Playing a game in the park for 30 minutes feels like a day with a
parent for many 4 and under children.
Over 5 however, due to maturation and education, these folks are
beginning to tell time and are moving away from the magical thinking of
the earlier level of children and living in the "here and now",
something that we Psychologists call "Concrete Operations", which is a
fancy word for thinking in the present and almost living in the moment.
This has positive and negative effects - on the positive side, they
can take some responsibility for managing some basic activities that
they are in the process of completing and have a very limited capacity
to remember details of the past. The bad news is that they cannot
think in the abstract and struggle when put into a position of having
to delay something planned ahead. This then causes frustration and
grief sometimes for the entire family.
The good news is that as children mature, such as with my almost
10 year old daughter, she is beginning to abstract and also think in
the past with greater ease which then tempers her frustration when she
might have to wait for a wished for activity. This process of
abstraction matched with the increased capacity to think in the past
increases through the adolescent years and so on. It also helps that
they can tell time.
These time realities must be taken in consideration by all parents
to help them better understand what their child is truly able to
comprehend or not and applied to all aspects of their child's life of
both parties, the child and the parent alike, will feel frustrated and
misunderstood. The ages where most parents seem to struggle the most
is with the school age children getting them ready for school, getting
them to bed, and holding them accountable for activities that are in
the future. Remember, they are only thinking "right now". If we apply
this concept to bedtime, which might be in 15 minutes, the parent then
needs to alert the child that the clock is ticking in order to help
them to prepare for that less desired moment. This process helps move
the school-age child into thinking a little ahead and also reduces
impending frustration. I even suggest considering a count down
regiment rather than a timer because timers cannot talk. Such a
technique, when used with a soft and empathic tone, can help the parent
of the school aged child to tolerate their frustration "times" much
easier which is helpful to all in the household.
Key Points:
1. Children perceive time differently depending upon their age.
2. Often times, developmental milestones can explain struggles rather than assuming psychological problems.
3. Parents need to understand differences in time processing when talking with their children
4. Never assume that your child understands time in the same way that you do.
Dr. Keith Kanner/ Morning Show Host
Your Family Matters
Fox 6 News
San Diego Living Show
8253 Ronson Road, San Diego 92111
ph (619) 261-2346/ (858) 756-3050
drkanner@fox6.com